Soylent Green… is PEOPLE!

Another one from Anne:

“Ethanolics Unanimous
posted June 21, 2007

Once again, we find our political leadership united around a very bad idea, ethanol and other biofuels to help gain “energy independence,” to “help farmers” and most importantly, to help citizens avoid the harsh reality of peak oil converging with unsustainable lifestyles. It is understandable that the politicians must pander to the corn growing states in anticipation of election cycles. Politicians have always been prostitutes for votes. Even the most enlightened, progressive, and thoughtful of them have fallen prey to this cornographic behavior.

While some crops are superior to others and forest eating cellulostic ethanol technology scams are still in development, corn ethanol primacy is devouring the nation’s alternative energy focus. Billions of taxpayer dollars are being thrown into this unsustainable technology and we subsidize each gallon of auto alcohol to the tune of 51 cents per gallon. The ethanol fumes are leaving us drunk on delusion, ignoring the consequences and refusing to face the future when the oil dries up.

To grow enough corn for ethanol to replace our oil addiction would require approximately 482 million acres of cropland, exceeding the current total of 434 million acres of cropland used for all food and fiber. This does not even account for projected growth of oil consumption in the U.S. There is already the push to put the marginal Conservation Reserve Program lands, vital for wildlife and water quality and quantity, into intense energy crop production.

Old school ethical farmers in the corn belt are already lamenting the destruction of soil saving windbreaks, some planted during the CCC years, the plowing under of hayfields to corn, highly erodable hilly lands being put into corn, and water drainages being reduced, hearkening back to the depression era insanity that squandered so much vital topsoil. Cellulostic ethanol scams will fare even worse for the soils as “residues” are scooped up, leaving virtually nothing to feed back to the soil.

“The nation that destroys its soil, destroys itself,” said President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

In the rush to burn our nation’s dwindling soil resources, corn is king. Corn devours soil nutrients at 12-20 times the rate of soil renewal, meaning it is already a highly unsustainable crop. Corn is also highly dependent on fossil fuel based fertilizer and pesticide inputs. With the inevitable hybridization and Genetically Modified Organism corn crops, the soil nutrient depletion will accelerate. The Corn Cartel, led by the likes of Archer Daniels Midland and Monsanto, have been working for decades on their plans for corn dominion over the U.S. and are now reaping record profits and subsidies.

Meanwhile, back on the farm, in addition to the land ethics meltdown, prime farmland prices have soared, rents have become prohibitive to all but the largest agribusiness operations, and again, the small farmers, the backbone, are being winnowed out like so much chaff. Seed, fuel and fertilizer costs are rising to meet the increased profit per bushel and farmers find themselves back on that familiar treadmill, the promise falling short as it always has.

In a land already plagued with poisoned groundwater, the incidence of atrazine and other poisons will only become more pervasive. Aquifers, already drained faster than recharge will only dry up faster in direct proportion to our ethanol consumption. It takes around 8,000 gallons of water to produce a gallon of ethanol from corn and each gallon of it leaves eight gallons of toxic waste sludge. Even in the land of 10,000 Lakes, Minnesota is experiencing water shortages from the ethanol production explosion. With 99% of corn production under intensive fossil fuel nitrogen fertilization regimes, there is a directly proportionate resulting contamination of surface and groundwater and growth of the dead zones where our rivers drain.

Depending on if you believe the science of the Corn Growers Association or scientists from Cornell University, corn will produce slightly more energy than is required to turn it into ethanol or substantially less. Having monitored the bioenergy crowd for a decade, repeated inquiries into true sustainability have been met with deafening silence. There is no ethanol plant in operation that can plant, grow, harvest, transport, process, and transport it’s product on ethanol alone and still show a profit. It cannot be done given today’s economics.

Ethanol also contains only 70% of the energy of gasoline. Therefore, it takes much more ethanol to go a hundred miles than it takes gas, undermining the 10 cent price difference at the pump that seems like you are saving money and the earth. Ethanol blends also evaporate far more readily causing a toxic nauseous moment at the pump and increasing ozone pollution. With the EPA poised to adjust ozone pollution standards to actually protect people, and Chattanooga’s history of barely tolerable air, it is unconscionable for the ethanol bandwagon committee here to be falling for this scam.

Today, communities across the cornucopian landscape are fighting proposed ethanol plants on issues from water consumption, water quality, noxious fumes, noise, traffic safety, and other quality of life issues.

Meanwhile, back at the grocery store…

Do we feed cars or ourselves. To fuel the average American consumer’s driving habits would require 11 acres of cropland per year, the same cropland that could feed seven people for a year. Already we’ve seen tortilla riots in Mexico and other places where corn is a food staple and the 60% price increase is prohibitive for the least affluent amongst us.

Ethanol primacy is in direct competition for the dairy and animal industry. In the US, the USDA projects that the wholesale price of chicken will be 10% higher this year, the price of eggs up 21%, milk 14%, beef 6% and this is only the beginning. Other food crops like soybeans, wheat, barley are being plowed under to feed cars instead. Already in Germany there is a shortage of barley leading the good Germans to fear for the future of their beer. In Mexico, blue agave tequila plantations are being burned and plowed under for corn, leaving those in Margaritaville far less happy while on vacation. And again, the small farmers of the US and elsewhere will be washed out as agribusiness always wins like the other Casinos do.

After we do the inevitable Enron-style bailout of the ethanol scamsters, we will be left with soils so depleted of basic nutrients, that any subsequent food production will be lower in nutrients, adversely affecting human and animal health and well being.

Indonesian and Brazilian rainforests are falling for ethanol and bioenergy production, slavery is making a comeback, peasants are being driven further into the forests, paramilitary corn cartels are stealing land in Columbia, endangered species are on the run and unmindful consumers of the over-developed world keep on consuming with nary a thought.

The ethanol scam will only accelerate global warming. As forests are cleared, more carbon is released than could ever possibly be avoided by burning ethanol. The mere act of using ethanol as a panacea to keep consumption and the American Weigh alive and unwell, will keep consumers unmindful and uncaring. Politically, that is what this whole snake/corn oil boondoggle is all about. To paraphrase the Jack Nicholson line…”We can’t handle the truth..about corn, peak oil, unsustainable lifestyles and how we’re ripping off future generations.” The switchgrass crowd, biodiesel crowd, and others intent on devouring soil and landscapes, might be somewhat less devastating, but the same problems will exist to the degree that the earth’s ability to support us declines and the other degrees continue to rise.

Now what…

If we poured trillions of dollars in subsidies to the oil and corn industries and untold resources into truly sustainable technologies, we could actually avert the worst case scenario of the end of oil and ensuing chaos and anarchy. Hard-Pour Cornography has us all cornfused for now, as our politicians and policies pander to the oil and corn cartels. Consumption based taxation on fuels, vastly improved mileage standards with current technology and technology in development, supporting improvements in solar, wind and storage technologies, car pooling, a conscientious and ethical public, combined with our ingenuity and technical prowess, we could develop truly sustainable options without a noticeable impact on our sacred standard of living like we’re the only creatures on the planet.

There is a reason that Toyota is now the biggest auto dealer in the US…innovation and mileage. The Chevy Volt is promising to get 150 mpg, mostly driven by electricity. Solar technology is on the verge of becoming competitive to the earth raping, subsidized technologies of ripping mountain tops off for coal, mining and leaving nuclear waste for 10,000 generations to deal with, and oil wars that kill and maim millions. Decentralized solar and wind could power virtually all of our current home and transportation needs. If we quit driving our food an average of 1,500 miles per bite and bought locally, lived within our means as communities and individuals, we might find an actual higher quality of life as we re-create communities based on our old values of taking care of the planet for future generations, living by the golden rule, and being tough enough to figure things out and do right. Just sit down by your car and take a swig of your favorite ethanol beverage, share a shot with your SUV, and ponder ways to avert disaster and the bad-mouthing of us by who is left of posterity.

Denny Haldeman
Soddy Daisy”


4 responses

  1. jess

    While I agree with the basic article that corn is not the answer, I find it very hard to go along with the liberal philosophy of “going back to our roots”. The liberals will have us eating trees and grass while staying in caves with no fire if we follow their direction.

    July 25, 2007 at 10:42 am

  2. I always find it interesting how anti-liberals tend to exaggerate to the point of absurdity what would happen if “liberals had their way.” If a liberal had been president, we’d be under Taliban control today. If liberals were in control, we’d have been obliterated from the face of the earth. You know… slippery slope stuff, but instead of stopping at the bottom, you keep digging as deeply as you can.

    I could almost hear a rousing cheer followed by a collective belch after your last line.

    Let’s bring it back down to earth, shall we? Liberals don’t want you to eat trees and grass and live in caves. Listen to what “liberals” are saying instead of what Fox News tell you what liberals MEAN.

    We weren’t put on this planet to rape and pillage its resources. We’re not smarter than the Earth, and we need to stop acting like we are.

    And it’s time to grow up and stop treating the environment and global warming as political issues, and treat them as survival issues.

    Maybe it’s so simple that it’s hard for people to understand: Don’t waste so much. Practice moderation. Take care of what you have so you can give it to your children.

    July 25, 2007 at 1:47 pm

  3. I hate that we politicize everything. In investing, it’s generally a good middle-of-the-road policy to take some risks, but also not to put all your eggs in one basket, and diversify.

    Why can’t we do this with issues of mega-importance like crime, health care, energy, pollution?

    Because it’s money, again. We don’t have a proper dollar value on the incentives to create new technologies (we can when the motivation is there; we can really do amazing things) or when it is smart to diversify.

    It’s that trying to move the mountains–the people with vested monetary and power interests–is a really hard thing.

    Our pioneer spirit needs to be tempered with some care for other people, including our kids. Maybe we should have a mandatory travel program for youth in the U.S. Go see how other places have a good life without hoarding everything.

    July 27, 2007 at 9:43 am

  4. Denny Haldeman

    It’s not a liberal vs. wingnut issue. We are at or approaching peak oil, are well past peak soil and water, and we will be forced back to those roots, whether you believe it or not. All the indicators show that we are currently highly unsustainable and the crash in inevitable. With what remains of our morality, we can soften that crash and hopefully minimize the anarchy, violence and widespread death. IT is a moral imperative that we seek actual solutions and quit lying to ourselves and each other.

    During the second World War, people willingly sacrificed at home and abroad to avert a tragic world in the making. As the tragedy unfolds for this far less than greatest generation, we have no sense of duty to our fellow humans or the world we leave to posterity. A thousand small individual steps by billions will have a ripple effect and could easily avert the worst case scenario.

    A number of folks like myself, have begun the process, reduced our impact considerably and have maintained a quality of life that is quite comfortable. My household budget is around 20-30 Kilowatts per month, all harvested from the sun via solar panels. I have lights, music, internet, etc…no sacrifice. When embarks on being mindful, it’s a joy to find ways to do things with minimal impacts. My cave (house) is warm and cool in the appropriate seasons, was built to maximize solar gain in the winter and avoid it in the summer, and requires less than a tenth of the energy per sq. ft. than the typically poorly designed and built american box that can’t be lived in without AC and coal fired power plants.

    It is unconscionable to kill our soils and relegate our foodstuffs and seed stocks to feed SUVs because we are too lazy, too full of ourselves, too greedy, and too unimaginative or tough enough to buck up and do right.

    I was raised on a farm where we grew virtually all of our food, ate the healthiest food of my life, where neighbors knew each other and worked together and it was considered a very rich life. No sacrifice was in the mind of those folks..far from it. There will be a forced return to those times when the oil runs out. It is a matter of time only. It is a mere matter of ethics and strength to do right now to conserve enough of our life support system to end up there with healthy soils, sustainable technologies, and imaginative solutions. Ethanol is a cop-out, a suicidal one. Denny

    August 29, 2007 at 12:33 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s